PEOPLE caught up with the pals in London for a story in this week's issue and asked what their most marketable assets would be if they were to craft Tinder profiles for one another. Apparently, it's all about the eyes!
Cooper, 40, got downright poetic talking about his costar's peepers: "[Her] reptilian eyes take you into a kind place, soft and lovely and full of grace."
For her part, Stone, 26, playfully reads even more into Cooper's baby blues – including takeout preferences – telling PEOPLE: "Look at those blue [eyes]. He’s into Chinese food, but he’s equally into making you smile."
While they had some fun joking about it, both say they aren't on the dating app – though Easy A alum Stone has done some swiping of her own.
"My friend is [on Tinder], and I’ve swiped for her," she says. "That was a good time."