How Jay Z's Tidal Press Conference Showed He's Out of Touch

Mar 31, 2015

After its splashy launch press conference yesterday, the primary argument for Tidal—the two-tiered music service recently purchased by Jay Z that costs either $9.99 or $19.99 per month—is that artists deserve more money for their work. It's not necessarily a wrongheaded argument, but the manner in which Jay Z and his contemporaries have pressed the point is embarrassingly out-of-touch.

Sign up for THE BRIEF and more. View Sample

There are real, systemic problems with current streaming services like Spotify, which stream music for free to listeners and distribute to artists a paltry fee drawn from advertising. That's why Taylor Swift withdrew her hugely profitable catalog from the service last year. The argument Swift has been making is that music has inherent value; from her statements regarding Spotify to her op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, it's a point she's consistently made well. The argument Jay Z and his fellow stars at the Tidal launch (including Nicki Minaj, Madonna, and Beyoncé) are making is that they deserve to set the price point for their music. The supporting evidence for this claim? They want to set the price point for their music.

The rhetoric around Tidal was pretty funny, when it wasn't embarrassing. A promotional video showed various celebrities gathering to discuss their master plan as Beyoncé, who would seem to know better, said "Every great movement started with a group of people being able to get together and really just make a stand." From Seneca Falls, to Selma, to Stonewall, to Los Angeles, where a bunch of celebrities demanded that their fans give them more money—this country has such a rich history of protest movements.

Jokes aside, the celebrities at the Tidal launch press conference did a remarkably poor job of elucidating why the consumer accustomed to getting music for free should begin paying for it. In the age of Spotify, it is entirely legal to listen to music constantly and never spend money on it. Countering that fact with the moral claim that celebrities would prefer if you didn't stream music for free only makes sense if you believe celebrities should get everything they want, one hundred percent of the time.

As for the rhetoric in the press conference that music is special and has a unique place in our culture: Music fans agree! That's why they listen to music often, on services that provide that music for free. But rather than building a better system, Jay Z and friends have, so far, put their energy behind a product that's more or less the same as Spotify, but more expensive. A product this pointless could, maybe, be sold as a charity case by artists who depend on every penny of fan support. But Jay Z, a rapper who wastes no opportunity to brag, on his records, about his business acumen, is not that figure. Based on the optics of the Tidal launch, his business acumen may have failed him this time.

Read next: This Is What Computers Look Like Now and That’s Just Awesome

Listen to the most important stories of the day.

Artists Who Have Never Won A Grammy

Photo of QUEEN
VIEW GALLERY | 23 PHOTOS
QueenJohn Rodgers—Redferns/Getty Images
Photo of QUEEN
'60s R&B Quintet "Jackson 5"
Spice Girls
Pepsi Super Bowl XLIX Halftime Show
RBC Royal Bank Bluesfest - Ottawa, ON
Diana Ross Performs In Dublin
2014 iHeartRadio Music Festival - Night 1 - Show
Janis Joplin
Photo of Patti SMITH
"How The West Was Won" Tour - Irvine, CA
Photo of Jimi HENDRIX
The Who
Photo of Jim MORRISON and DOORS
Led Zeppelin File Photos
Photo of Flavor FLAV and Chuck D and PUBLIC ENEMY
Journey
Kiss
Photo of Run DMC
The Ramones
Andre Agassi's 6th Grand Slam for Children Fundraiser - Show
Fun Fun Fun Fest 2014
Iggy Pop 1988
Kid Rock In Concert
Queen
John Rodgers—Redferns/Getty Images
1 of 23
All products and services featured are based solely on editorial selection. TIME may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.