• Newsfeed
  • celebrity

Watch the American Idol Judges Assess New PEEPS-Flavored Milk

1 minute read

As we reported last week, PEEPS-flavored milk is now a real thing you can put into your body. Jimmy Kimmel was curious about this new seasonal beverage, so he decided to try it — and he recruited the American Idol judges to test it out too.

“It’s PEEPS-flavored milk,” he said on Tuesday’s episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live! “Because in this busy fast-paced world, who has time to chew their marshmallows?” Kimmel, who says the milk “tastes like the circus,” isn’t a huge fan. He adds: “It tastes like what I imagine it would taste like to be breastfed by a mother clown.”

Later, the American Idol judges — Jennifer Lopez, Keith Urban and Harry Connick, Jr. — tried some and were much more polite. (Well, Harry and Keith like it. Jen finds it just too sugary.) If only Simon Cowell were still a judge, we’re sure he’d have some very mean but clever things to say.

Celebrities Who Look Uncannily Alike

Jessica Chastain & Bryce Dallas HowardGetty Images (2)
Orlando Bloom & Luke EvansGetty Images (2)
Javier Bardem & Jeffrey Dean MorganGetty Images (2)
Minka Kelly & Leighton MeesterGetty Images (2)
Daniel Radcliffe & Elijah WoodGetty Images (2)
Will Ferrell & Chad SmithGetty Images (2)
Henry Cavill & Matt BomerGetty Images (2)
Tom Hardy & Logan Marshall-GreenGetty Images (2)
Natalie Portman & Keira KnightleyGetty Images (2)
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau & Josh HollowayGetty Images (2)
Mark Ruffalo & Chris MessinaGetty Images (2)
Jeremy Irons & Daniel Day-LewisGetty Images (2)
Johnny Depp & John Mayer Getty Images (2)
Mila Kunis & Sarah HylandGetty Images (2)
Zachary Quinto & Eli RothGetty Images (2)
Will Arnett & Patrick WilsonGetty Images (2)
Ryan Gosling & Ryan ReynoldsGetty Images (2)

More Must-Reads From TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com