Joseph Clancy
Acting Secret Service Director Joseph Clancy testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington, in 2014. Susan Walsh—AP

Top Republican Watchdog Slams Secret Service Director Pick

Feb 18, 2015

A top Republican critic of former Secret Service director Julia Pierson is not pleased with the Obama Administration's pick to be her successor.

House Oversight and Government Reform Chairman Jason Chaffetz said Wednesday that the appointment of acting director Joseph Clancy contradicts the recommendation of an independent panel created by the Department of Homeland Security in the aftermath of the embarrassing White House fence-jumping incident in September. Clancy's appointment over Sean Joyce, a former deputy director of the F.B.I, extends the agency's 150-year history of being led by a Secret Service agent, according to the New York Times.

"Only a director from outside the Service, removed from organizational traditions and personal relationships, will be able to do the honest top-to-bottom reassessment this will require," argued the report, which was released in mid-December.

Chaffetz said in a statement that it was "disappointing" the President "ignored" the panel's recommendations.

"The panel made it crystal clear that only a director from outside the agency would meet the needs of the agency today—someone with a fresh perspective, free from allegiances and without ties to what has consistently been described as a ‘good old boys network,'" he said. “The good men and women of the Secret Service are screaming for a fresh start. At this moment in time, the Secret Service would best be served by a transformative and dynamic leader from outside the agency."

Pierson, the first female Secret Service director, resigned on Oct. 1, a day after a poor performance before Chaffetz's committee and revelations that an armed security contractor with an arrest record was improperly screened and allowed onto an elevator with the President. A last straw for Pierson was that she did not inform Obama of the security breach.

Chaffetz wished the best for Clancy even if he disagreed with the appointment. Maryland Rep. Elijah Cummings, the top Democrat on the Oversight committee, said he was also ready to work with the new director.

“Joe Clancy has taken strong action over the past several months to begin righting the ship at the Secret Service, he has been extremely responsive to Congress, and his decisive leadership has already resulted in major changes," said Cummings. "I look forward to working with him closely over the next year to ensure that the Secret Service gets what it needs to fulfill its critical mission.”

All products and services featured are based solely on editorial selection. TIME may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.